Mikaela or Carly?

[i-MAN]

Rosie (Carly), she really surprised me with her performance in DOTM !

[Albershide]

No doubts that Rosie did a great job in the movie, but I'm sure that if I asked you after ROTF, do you want Megan to return for TF3 or you want another actress, 90% of the people would answer that they want Megan, right? So no doubts that the movie suffered a little bit, but it was a necessary sacrifice.

[CesarCardoso]

No doubts that Rosie did a great job in the movie, but I'm sure that if I asked you after ROTF, do you want Megan to return for TF3 or you want another actress, 90% of the people would answer that they want Megan, right? So no doubts that the movie suffered a little bit, but it was a necessary sacrifice.

i'm not sure i'd say yes. obviously i expected her to be in it because of the first 2 movies but i was getting a bit fed up with the her attitude towards Sam. I also got the impression that she was staying with him out of some sort of duty, not out of love. The line "Who else could be your girlfriend?" made me think she had second thoughts.

[starscream1017]

The line "Who else could be your girlfriend?" made me think she had second thoughts.

that line didnt look like she had second thoughts, that ment who else would go through everything being with him put her through, constant danger, being shot at, who else would go through that? carly sure as hell wouldn't! she split for the party at the first chance she had.

[CesarCardoso]

that line didnt look like she had second thoughts, that ment who else would go through everything being with him put her through, constant danger, being shot at, who else would go through that? carly sure as hell wouldn't! she split for the party at the first chance she had.

it wasnt a party, it was a work dinner!

[Primes_Girl81]

I think carlys and mikaelas prioritys were alot more different. I mean there definitely was a connection between mikaela and sam not so much with carly, but thats probably because they didn't have enough time together as mikaela and sam had 2 whole movies to develop their relationship. Throughout the 2 movies you can definitely see mikaelas love and devotion for sam whereas you cannot with carly.

[UltraPrime]

Rosie any day. Don't like spoiled bitchy people like Megan.

[David123]

Mikaela, it was all Carly's fault that lord Megatron wound up with an axe through his nut.

[Flyingheart]

I just read an article and there was a picture next to it of Rosie... i voted Rosie... sorry Megan.
Mann.. Rosie is soooo... ss..... ...xx ...yy XD

[warhorse]

that line didnt look like she had second thoughts, that ment who else would go through everything being with him put her through, constant danger, being shot at, who else would go through that? carly sure as hell wouldn't! she split for the party at the first chance she had.

That's true! She was already bitching Sam out because he wanted to help the Autobots. Mikaela would not only support him, she'd be practically dragging him out the door, because she would want to join!

Too bad Mikaela wasn't in the movie, they still could of just dyed Rosie's hair brunette, with all of the other inconsistencies throughout the trilogy, I'm sure her new accent would have just been a blip on the radar. Would love to see her whip out some knife and cut off one of Soundwave's tentacles!

[warhorse]

I just read an article and there was a picture next to it of Rosie... i voted Rosie... sorry Megan.
Mann.. Rosie is soooo... ss..... ...xx ...yy XD

I think you're missing the point of this thread! Let me just say, if Mikaela and Carly had a fight, Mikaela would have knocked out Carly with one punch, and probably knocked out Dylan with the other punch!

[BrunnerD]

Agreed, Mikaela would of won. Carly is awesome but Fox is great to. Just my opinion though, I have nothing to complain about either anymore, two different characters.

[Flyingheart]

I think you're missing the point of this thread! Let me just say, if Mikaela and Carly had a fight, Mikaela would have knocked out Carly with one punch, and probably knocked out Dylan with the other punch!

Oh ok.. i dont know this thread is kind of vage for me.. why doesnt the thread say "Cat/Bitch fight Mikeala Vs. Carly"?? was more clear to me.. but i guess Mikeala is more of a tomboy so she can punch pretty good but i think she's missing the strength for it so i have my money on Rosie with her face-scratching and hair pulling abilities PLUS she already has learned the backstabbing tactics from the modeling carreer

Rosie! Rosie! Rosie! will this be on the Blu-ray extra's as well?

[starscream1017]

Oh ok.. i dont know this thread is kind of vage for me.. why doesnt the thread say "Cat/Bitch fight Mikeala Vs. Carly"?? was more clear to me.. but i guess Mikeala is more of a tomboy so she can punch pretty good but i think she's missing the strength for it so i have my money on Rosie with her face-scratching and hair pulling abilities PLUS she already has learned the backstabbing tactics from the modeling carreer

Rosie! Rosie! Rosie! will this be on the Blu-ray extra's as well?

man, i would love to be the ref in that match!! but i wouldn't be a fair one.. will probably hand mikeala a steel chair or something!

just saw this vid, rosie had to learn how to run! :lmao
no wonder we dont see her running. while mikaela was running through timed explosives! if it was rosie, she would have blown up!

[taybrian1]

I don't know. Carly jut struck me as way too prissy. If you are going to date a man that saved the world twice, you have to be able to get down and dirty.

[warhorse]

I wonder, what Eliza Dushku could bring to the table if she played Mikaela???????

[starscream1017]

I wonder, what Eliza Dushku could bring to the table if she played Mikaela???????

i like her.

[Mr Majestic]

Carly is the thinking man's crumpet, Mikaela is for the young, dumb, mindless masses.

[starscream1017]

i dont know why ppl think carly is sophisticated and classy. i think its just the british accent that gets ppl.. and ppl think megan is a sl** just cause she oozes sexuality..
do a google image search of both of them.. you'll find loads of naked pics of rosie and 0 of megan (not counting the fake photoshopped ones)
besides Megan has 4 flicks coming out, some are big ones, where as most ppl seem to have forgotten rosie. other than possibly being in the next bay flick, i doubt she is going to get much work.. she just hasnt blown up the way megan did.. ppl dont really care..

[sora]

Let's not go there ("which actress is nicer/hottier" convo). After all, it's Sam's relationship. Maybe it was just that he prefered more girly type rather than a tomboyish mechanic.

[LOVEME2]

MIKAELA!

rosie's rol was more like megan's part.

Is easy to remove a name and put other name + and 1,2 (stupid) scenes..about how they met...

[Link]

Carly is the thinking man's crumpet, Mikaela is for the young, dumb, mindless masses.

Basically that. I prefer Carly 'cause of my tastes.

[Mr Majestic]

For me it's nothing to do with the British accent... Rosie is a Victoria's secret model! I see women like Megan Fox around town all the time, yeah they look hot but you can see in their eyes that they have no soul or heart, they're literally just hot zombies lol. Rosie looks like the type of woman you can have actually have a relationship with (Jason Stratham is one lucky man!)

As for the characters, Mikaela seemed overly pretentious and slutty, Carly added a touch of class to Sams short list of girlfriends.

[chatterbox]

why? why all the fighting! theres no need for this. threesome. there. say it with me threesome! *shakes head* I mean both of them! both of them, why choose :P

[warhorse]

i like her.

Same here, ever since I saw her as a little kid in the movie That Night. She would be a handful of years older than her character, but she's like Juliet Lewis or Pauley Parrette, she simply doesn't age.