Do you think there's going to be or should be a Pirates 4?

[xAgonyxScenex]

Any thoughts? I know Johnny has expressed wanting to do more, and i know they hinted at a 4th at the end of 3. A lot of people expressed not liking the 2 last movies, though personally I think the movies were damn fun solid movies.

[r-type]

kiera knightley said no more.

I agree with her. Johnny Depp's Sparrow character was a pleasant surprise in the 1st one, but got tiresome as the series, Savvy? :p

My favorite character was actually Davy Jones (both the cgi and the actor Bill Nighy's performance) and he was treated as a footnote in the 3rd with a lame ass twist ending.

But your question is do I think there will be more? Probably. Two words: Cash Cow.

We may harp about how it sucked here on the boards, but the fact is they still filled the seats. So, it wouldn't surprise me if Brucks puts up another one.

[uraydo]

then explain the end to me, cause I didn't get it.



Spoiler***




Why didn't Elisabeth just join the crew of the Flying Dutchman so she could be with her loverboy for all eternity?

[r-type]

then explain the end to me, cause I didn't get it.



Spoiler***




Why didn't Elisabeth just join the crew of the Flying Dutchman so she could be with her loverboy for all eternity?

[DeNiro face]you talkin' to me?[DeNiro face]

Was it the fact that there was only a certain number of people (and didn't they have to be dead as well?) that could be on that boat? I don't remember that part of the story very well, because I was both cross-eyed and bored with all of the double crossings by the time the movie ended.

[xAgonyxScenex]

then explain the end to me, cause I didn't get it.



Spoiler***




Why didn't Elisabeth just join the crew of the Flying Dutchman so she could be with her loverboy for all eternity?

cause she was pregnant and didnt want that to be the babies life

[Moediaz2]

My fav character was Davy Jones aswell. I loved the special effects, and espcially The Kraken. The music was superb aswell, Klaus and Hans did a wonderful job.
I don't think they should make a 4th one, they did leave room for another one open.
The trilogy was enough for me, and it served each character rightful justice.


I wouldn't mind seeing a Treasue Island remake from Disney though.

[redqueenar]

Any thoughts? I know Johnny has expressed wanting to do more, and i know they hinted at a 4th at the end of 3. A lot of people expressed not liking the 2 last movies, though personally I think the movies were damn fun solid movies.

The last two were a bit of a mess, which was a shame because it was such a great concept. I'd love to see another one about Jack Sparrow and Barbossa. Those two could just torment each other for two hours while chasing after The Fountain of Youth and it'd be great. No need for Will Turner or Elizabeth, in my opinion.

[uraydo]

[DeNiro face]you talkin' to me?[DeNiro face]

Was it the fact that there was only a certain number of people (and didn't they have to be dead as well?) that could be on that boat? I don't remember that part of the story very well, because I was both cross-eyed and bored with all of the double crossings by the time the movie ended.
I was talking to Agony. I should have used a quote but i thought I was going to be post number two.

as I recall, they didn't have to be dead, and would think the captain could kick some people off if there wasn't room.

[Ricardo]

Don't think they should make a part 4. Afcourse they'll earn lots of money with it, but like with part 2 and 3, they got less exciting because you've seen all the good stuff in part 1 already.

[Duracell Bunny]

Number 1 was great, Number 2 was funny, number 3 was just..... something.

A Number 4? I hope not, and if they do, go back to the first films roots and make it special.

[Ricardo]

Number 1 was great, Number 2 was funny, number 3 was just..... something.

A Number 4? I hope not, and if they do, go back to the first films roots and make it special.

Yes, that is what I ment :). But to make it just a special as part 1 is very difficult because people now have 2 others movies to compare with.

[xXRavenXx]

Between Savy, Rum, Dirt, and all round over using a joke... I hope not. A lot comes from the writers seeing Johnny's work of the character and writing towards the character. So it wasn't Depp's work it was written so I don't think it came off with the same intent.

I love their stories, but it just seemed like the second was a giant set up and instead of making 1 good movie they made 2 cluster fucks. I'll say it again: I actually walked out of the third.

So as much as I like Cpt. Jack... No Pirates 4. R-type is right about the Cash Cow.

[Bumblebee1983]

Number 1 was great, Number 2 was funny, number 3 was just..... something.

A Number 4? I hope not, and if they do, go back to the first films roots and make it special.

Exactly what I was thinking. The first was the best.


Between Savy, Rum, Dirt, and all round over using a joke... I hope not. A lot comes from the writers seeing Johnny's work of the character and writing towards the character. So it wasn't Depp's work it was written so I don't think it came off with the same intent.

I love their stories, but it just seemed like the second was a giant set up and instead of making 1 good movie they made 2 cluster fucks. I'll say it again: I actually walked out of the third.

So as much as I like Cpt. Jack... No Pirates 4. R-type is right about the Cash Cow.

RUM?!? Who said rum? Where?

And as for the ending of three, that's where it should end. Will is the captain of the whatever-the-name-of-the-damn ship is....and Elizabeth has his heart on land. She has to keep it safe.

And she couldn't join the crew because she's not in between life and death.

The music was very good, too. Three of my playlists on my iPod. :D

I'm hungry.....sorry, random thought. :o

[r-type]

Exactly what I was thinking. The first was the best.



RUM?!? Who said rum? Where?

And as for the ending of three, that's where it should end. Will is the captain of the whatever-the-name-of-the-damn ship is....and Elizabeth has his heart on land. She has to keep it safe.

And she couldn't join the crew because she's not in between life and death.

The music was very good, too. Three of my playlists on my iPod. :D

I'm hungry.....sorry, random thought. :o
That's what I was trying to say (in bold) above to Urry. Thank you BB.

[Bumblebee1983]

That's what I was trying to say (in bold) above to Urry. Thank you BB.

Not a problem-o. :D